Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Consent Order Done. House Not Selling Despite Lowering Asking Price. Ex Now Wants Me to Buy Them Out Cheaper?

Posted by MrStudent 
Hi

We completed our consent order and it was approved in May. All amicable and seemingly straight forward.

The house has been on the market for 6 months and it has only had two viewings. We're currently switching agents after reducing the asking price by £10,000 and then £20,000 without success.

My ex wants their equity (I'm living in the house currently) which is fair enough. She has approached me asking me to make a buy out offer of less that the three valuations we had. However, our consent order clearly states we were to sell the house and split the equity 50/50.

In some ways it would be convenient to stay, and my new mortgage in principle would cover a buy-out, but I had hoped to sell and close this chapter of my life. I thought I might move to a city or maybe even try to work abroad. For context, the house is too big for me and in a rural area which I find isolating. It's got a fair bit of work that needs doing and it's quite cold in winter.

I considered what I'd need to spend on it and the idea of buying her out at £40,000 less than the valuation appeals but it's also not what I want long term. I'd probably hold on to it for two years and sell in the hope that markets improve and I can make enough to buy a small place outright.

The obvious issues are: the consent order would presumably need to be redone, the issue of fairness (her receiving £20000 less than she would if it sold at the current asking price), and the fact that hypothetically I wouldn't buy it at it's valuation price or want to stay long term.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/06/2026 04:29PM by MrStudent.
I suppose if you want to sell it and move on anyway it is a matter of reducing the price until you do get a buyer. Although you could buy your ex out at a reduced valuation there is nothing to say that valuation actually represents what the house would sell for. Also, of course, if you buy out her share you may just be postponing the difficulty of selling which then becomes your problem rather than hers. It depends on what is most important to you.
Presumably the consent order would need amending?
If there is what is called a 'liberty to apply' provision in the existing order it should be a relatively straightforward matter to amend it by consent.

It may be, though, that both parties would sufficiently protected simply by ensuring that the proposed agreement is properly recorded and acted upon so that there is good evidence to rely upon in the event of any later dispute.

You would be well advised to take formal legal advice before embarking on a course of action which differs from that set out in the existing order.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login