Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Reasonable offer?

Posted by jay25 
Reasonable offer?
July 21, 2026 11:19AM
I filed for divorce 2.5 years ago, my ex and I shared the home because I could not afford to move out but had to move out a month ago due to harrassment and arguments. She has had various business ventures over the years but has not had income in the last 8 years and has mainly cared for the children, who are now 20 and my daughter is due to turn 18 in December. I previously tried to negotiate with her without lawyers but I was concerned that I was being bullied by her to take a bad deal. She later got a lawyer, who started negotiating on her behalf while I self represented as I could not afford to pay for one while covering household bills. Our assets are one 2 bed flat worth about 500k with 150k equity (she purchased this and I was a guarantor)and wants to keep this. Then our family home has about 800k equity which she wants 60%, my pension has 120k which she also wants 50% of. She is also demanding 5 years spousal which would means she would stay in the family home till 2029 with me covering mortgage and expenses to the tune of about £3,500. I earn about 7k and earn about 140k a year with bonus. I have recently moved out but between covering all household bills and looking after kids expenses I am not really able to live or afford a place where the kids can sleep over. I recently borrowed money for a lawyer and have countered at 50/50 on family home with her moving into other property after 1 year of spousal (been paying full household with no contribution since decree nisi so I think she needs to start contributing or looking for work actively). Her lawywer recently came back refusing and not even countering. Looks like we will go to court but just want to sense check with neutral opinions.
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 21, 2026 11:29AM
Forgot to add, been married for 18 years, separated for a year and then been trying to divorce for 2.5 years.
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 23, 2026 04:24PM
Well, there are two properties which puts you in a better position than if there was just the family home. Also, the ages of the children are such that they are not likely to be dependent for that much longer.

Within that context it is hard to see why your ex should get to keep the flat and have 60% of the equity in the house. That proposed division looks unreasonable. Similarly it isn't obvious why 2029 is fair.

The downside is her lack of income compared to yours. That does probably mean that she needs more of the equity to provide for her housing needs but not as much as she is proposing. Courts do try to be fair so your housing needs also need to be taken into account and there is no good reason why you should have to live in inferior accommodation compared to your wife. It would have been different if the children were much younger but they are not.
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 24, 2026 08:03PM
Her lawyer has told her that she can get spousal till the youngest finishes higher education or university. That’s where she got the 2029 date from. Very early on she was pushing for 20 years and before that it was for the rest of her life. My last offer for her keeping the second home (which she collects rental income for without paying any bills in the family home), splitting 50/50 the family home & pension, me keeping the car (circa £18k), 1 year spousal before the house is sold and one year in the new home (total of 2) was rejected flat out without a counter. It is clear to me that her expectations will probably not be realistic so I will be preparing paper work via the Direct Access Scheme in order to go to court. I didn’t think my solicitor sending 2 emails back and forth to her solicitor was worth the £3k bill I got hit with. Do you think my offer is fair and do you have any recommendations for good barristers to work with on the Direct Access Scheme?
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 25, 2026 08:54AM
>>Her lawyer has told her that she can get spousal till the youngest finishes higher education or university.<<

I assumed that is where the 2029 came from but if this is the reason it should be expressed as such and not as some arbitrary date. \after all, the youngest may drop out of university or take never ending course. If this is the reason it should make that the limit and specify that it is limited to a first degree with no possibility of extension.

If your ex wants to keep the flat and receive the rent she needs to give credit for the fact that you are giving up your presumptive half share in the flat and receiving the rent by an appropriate reduction in the amount of maintenance payable.

I can't make recommendations because one tends to be held responsible for recommendations. I would say, though, that a direct access barrister is better suited to court hearings than negotiation by correspondence. If you think it might work mediation may help. You ex has shown some signs of movement so it is not beyond the bounds of possibility.
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 25, 2026 04:56PM
Thanks for your reply Terry. If she stays in the family home till 2029, she needs to accept 50/50 split, my reasoning is that full maintenance is circa £42k a year for another 2.5 years. As it stands since the decree nisi (2.5years) she has made no attempts to retrain or find work. She has recently picked up painting but has not sold anything enough to contribute to expenses. This was always part of the issue - not looking for work etc. Whereas if the family home was sold, maintenance would be lower due to a fully paid off mortgage on the second home and much more affordable on a mortgage free house. Re direct access, I only mentioned it because solicitor negotiations have not yielded any fruit, just a lot of bills. Which is why I am considering just going to court. Mediation was suggested to her before but she said she didn’t want to go.
Re: Reasonable offer?
July 26, 2026 08:39AM
Bearing in mind the ages of the children I think it is reasonable that your wife makes some effort to work or retrain going forward. Unless there is some history of being able to generate a meaningful income from it I cannot see painting cutting the mustard.

Similarly it is not reasonable to expect you to pay very high maintenance to cover a mortgage that would be unnecessary if your ex moved into another property suitable for her needs. Also, while she remains in the matrimonial home subject to a mortgage which you effectively pay for that will make it difficult for you to obtain a mortgage of your own. That also would be unacceptable except on a short term basis.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login